My wine cork on a string was the most made fun of ornament in the creative/whatever category. I ended up getting it back so I think that was fair. One of the best Made ornaments was this one from my best friend's mom who couldn't even make it to the party :( It looked bought off the shelf but it was definitely made. All the stars were strung around a circle to form a wreath and a HOHOHO ribbon was attached to hang it from the tree.
Everyone ended up leaving with 3 ornaments. The favorite of the three that I ended up with is this knit owl. (My owl addiction was first posted about here.) I loved him the moment I saw him, but I had to trade post-swap to get him.
And here he is chilling on the tree by himself since it's not decorated yet.
All in all it was a successful night. It may even become an annual thing!